Untitled Document

JNOV: Judgment Non Obstante Veredicto

Notwithstanding the Verdict

Tuesday, 05 July 2005

Do We Need Another Woman on the Court?
Posted by Daniel Austin Green on Tuesday, 05 July 2005, at 11:39 pm. 0 Trackbacks

A lot of people have suggested that the new Supreme Court justice ought to be a woman. Apparently (via How Appealing), this will be voiced on USA Today's op-ed page Wednesday (by Tony Mauro).

I'm somewhat ambivalent as to whether or not sex should really be a factor one way or the other. That said, it seems that the many of the best candidates (whether on the speculative short-lists or not) are women. Professor Todd Zywicki identifies two outstanding choices: Fifth Circuit Judge Edith Jones and Sixth Circuit Judge Alice Batchelder. Both are impeccably qualified, for the reasons Zywicki discusses.

And I'm a little surprised at so much Gonzales speculation. After all, mightn't Gonzales be "Spanish for Souter", even if "Al Gonzales is a great friend of [Bush]."